6 Infamous Small Town Murders
- Small Town Spots
- Jun 13
- 7 min read
Small towns, often celebrated for their close-knit communities and picturesque landscapes, can sometimes become the setting for grim and unexpected events. Murders in these seemingly tranquil locales can send shockwaves through the community, altering the perception of safety and trust. Here are some of the most notable small town murder cases.
The Black Donnellys
One of Canada's most infamous cases involves the Black Donnelly family in Lucan, Ontario. In the late 19th century, the family became embroiled in violent feuds with their neighbors, culminating in a brutal massacre in 1880. Despite several trials, no one was ever convicted, leaving the case shrouded in mystery and folklore.
The Donnelly family emigrated from Ireland during the mid-19th century, settling in the township of Biddulph, near Lucan. James and Johannah Donnelly, the family patriarch and matriarch, established a farm and raised seven children. The family quickly gained a reputation for their fiery tempers and involvement in local disputes.
The Donnellys' lives were marked by continuous feuds with their neighbors. These conflicts often escalated into violence, with the Donnellys being accused of theft, arson, and other crimes. The community was divided; some viewed the Donnellys as troublemakers, while others saw them as victims of prejudice and injustice.
The tensions reached a climax on February 4, 1880, when a vigilante mob attacked the Donnelly homestead. In a brutal act of frontier justice, they murdered five members of the family. The event sparked outrage and became a national sensation, highlighting the lawlessness of the time.
The murderers were never convicted, and the case remains unsolved, shrouded in mystery and speculation. Over the years, the story of the Black Donnellys has become a part of Canadian folklore, inspiring books, plays, and even television adaptations.
The Murder of Lynne Harper
In 1959, 12-year-old Lynne Harper was murdered in the small town of Clinton, Ontario. Steven Truscott, a 14-year-old schoolmate, was wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death. Decades later, new evidence led to his acquittal, highlighting issues with the justice system in rural areas.
On the evening of June 9, Lynne Harper was last seen riding on the handlebars of a bicycle with her friend, Steven Truscott, who was 14 years old at the time. The two reportedly parted ways near a wooded area, and Lynne never returned home. Her parents reported her missing, and a search ensued.
Lynne's body was discovered two days later in a nearby wooded area. The examination revealed that she had been sexually assaulted and strangled. The investigation quickly focused on Steven Truscott, largely due to the fact that he was the last known person to see her alive.
Steven Truscott was arrested and charged with Lynne Harper's murder. The trial began in September 1959 and was closely followed by the public and media. Despite the lack of physical evidence directly linking him to the crime, the prosecution's case was built on circumstantial evidence and testimony that placed him at the scene.
The trial lasted for 15 days, and the jury found Steven Truscott guilty of murder. He was initially sentenced to death by hanging, making him the youngest person to receive such a sentence in Canada. However, due to public outcry and appeals for clemency, his sentence was commuted to life imprisonment.
Years later, the case was re-examined due to persistent doubts about Truscott's guilt. In 2007, after a lengthy legal review, the Ontario Court of Appeal overturned Truscott's conviction, declaring it a miscarriage of justice. The court found that the original investigation and trial were flawed, and Truscott was exonerated.
The Lynne Harper case highlighted significant issues within the Canadian justice system, leading to reforms in how juvenile suspects are treated and how evidence is handled. It remains a poignant reminder of the importance of a fair trial and the potential consequences of judicial errors. The case continues to be a subject of study and discussion among legal experts and historians.
The Villisca Axe Murders
In the early 20th century, the quiet town of Villisca, Iowa, was forever changed by a gruesome crime. On June 10, 1912, the Moore family and two guests were brutally murdered with an axe while they slept. Despite numerous investigations and several suspects, the case remains unsolved. The Villisca Axe Murders are a chilling reminder that even small, close-knit communities are not immune to tragedy.
The Keddie Cabin Murders
In the serene and picturesque setting of the Sierra Nevada Mountains in Northern California, a seemingly idyllic vacation spot turned into the center of a chilling mystery that has puzzled investigators and gripped true crime enthusiasts for decades. Known as the Keddie Cabin Murders, this case remains one of the most infamous unsolved crimes in American history.
Keddie, a small, unincorporated community, was once a bustling resort town in the early 20th century. By the 1980s, it had become a quiet retreat for families seeking respite from the hustle and bustle of urban life. Nestled within this tranquil locale was Cabin 28, a modest wooden structure that would soon become infamous.
On the morning of April 12, 1981, Sheila Sharp, a teenager returning from a sleepover next door, discovered a gruesome scene inside her family’s cabin. The bodies of her mother, Glenna “Sue” Sharp, her brother John, and his friend Dana Wingate lay lifeless, victims of a brutal attack. The crime was characterized by extreme violence, with evidence suggesting that the victims had been bound, bludgeoned, and stabbed. The scene inside Cabin 28 was chaotic, indicating a ferocious struggle. Remarkably, three young children were found unharmed in an adjacent bedroom, seemingly oblivious to the horror that had unfolded mere feet away. However, Sheila’s sister, Tina Sharp, was missing, adding another layer of mystery to the already perplexing case.
The investigation into the Keddie Cabin Murders was fraught with challenges from the outset. The remoteness of the location, coupled with the limited resources of local law enforcement, hampered efforts to gather evidence and pursue leads effectively. Despite these hurdles, authorities managed to uncover some key pieces of evidence, including a bloody hammer and a bent steak knife.
Numerous suspects and theories emerged over the years, but none led to a definitive conclusion. The investigation was marred by allegations of mishandling, with crucial evidence reportedly lost or overlooked. In 1984, remains later identified as those of Tina Sharp were discovered nearly 30 miles away from Keddie, deepening the enigma surrounding the case.
The Clutter Family Murders
The small town of Holcomb, Kansas, was thrust into the national spotlight in 1959 with the murder of the Clutter family. Herb Clutter, his wife Bonnie, and their two teenage children were found brutally murdered in their home. The senseless killings were later immortalized in Truman Capote's true crime novel, "In Cold Blood." The murderers, Perry Smith and Richard Hickock, were eventually captured, tried, and executed, but the chilling nature of the crime continues to haunt Holcomb.
Herbert Clutter, a successful and respected farmer, lived with his family in a modest yet comfortable farmhouse. The family included Herbert's wife, Bonnie, and their two youngest children, Nancy and Kenyon. The Clutters were well-regarded in their community, known for their generosity and involvement in local activities.
On the night of November 15, 1959, the peaceful town of Holcomb was shattered by the brutal murder of the Clutter family. Richard "Dick" Hickock and Perry Smith, two ex-convicts, broke into the Clutter home with the intention of stealing money they believed was hidden in a safe—a safe that did not exist. Finding no money, the desperate duo bound and gagged the family members before shooting them at close range. This senseless act of violence left the community in shock and mourning.
The investigation into the Clutter family murder was intensive and thorough. The Kansas Bureau of Investigation (KBI) led the efforts to track down the perpetrators. The breakthrough came when a former cellmate of Hickock provided information about the planned robbery, leading investigators to the suspects. The case has become widely regarded as the catalyst for increased public interest in such crimes, as a result of its extensive media coverage.
Ed Gein: The Butcher of Plainfield
Edward Theodore Gein, born on August 27, 1906, in La Crosse, Wisconsin, was raised in a strict and isolated environment by his mother, Augusta. She was a domineering and religious woman who instilled in Gein a fear of the outside world and a disdain for women, considering them instruments of sin. This upbringing had a profound impact on Gein's psyche and future actions.
Ed Gein became infamous for his gruesome crimes committed in and around the small town of Plainfield, Wisconsin, during the late 1950s. After the death of his mother in 1945, Gein's mental state deteriorated, leading him to engage in macabre activities. His fascination with death and the female body led him to exhume corpses from local graveyards, using their skin and bones for various purposes.
The investigation into Ed Gein's crimes began when local hardware store owner Bernice Worden went missing. Her disappearance on November 16 raised alarm, particularly because it occurred during the busy deer hunting season. Suspicion quickly fell on Ed Gein, who had been seen in the store the previous evening and was one of the last people to have had contact with Worden.
The investigation led authorities to Gein's isolated farmhouse on the outskirts of Plainfield. Upon entering the premises, they made a gruesome discovery: Worden's body was found decapitated and hung in a manner similar to that of a hunter dressing a deer. Further searches revealed a house filled with macabre items, including human skulls, pieces of human skin fashioned into household items, and various body parts.
Ed Gein was promptly arrested and taken into custody. His capture not only solved the mystery of Bernice Worden's disappearance but also brought to light numerous other unsolved cases and missing persons reports. The sheer horror of his crimes captivated the nation and inspired numerous books and films including, "Psycho," as well as, "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre" and, "The Silence of the Lambs."
Comments